Center for Business and Economic Research - Ball State University


CBER Data Center
Projects and PublicationsEconomic IndicatorsWeekly CommentaryCommunity Asset InventoryManufacturing Scorecard

About

Commentaries are published weekly and distributed through the Indianapolis Business Journal and many other print and online publications. Disclaimer

RSS Feed

Disclaimer

The views expressed in these commentaries do not reflect those of Ball State University or the Center for Business and Economic Research.

Recent

Two Key Economic Lessons in One BillHoosiers face trade-offs and opportunity costs in the wake of SEA1.

Time to Fix Economic Development PolicyAllocating tax dollars to land development won’t cause economic growth.

The Unanticipated Effects of SB1Businesses, governments and households may all feel the effects.

The Stupidest of PoliciesThis whipsawing of tariff rates has unnerved financial markets, which on Wednesday, were toying with a liquidity crisis.

View archives

Top Tags

jobs and employment 261
economics 201
state and local government 188
education 186
economic development 171
indiana 171
budget and spending 145
taxes 144
law and public policy 142
workforce and human capital 139
Browse all tags
Reporter / Admin Login

January 17, 2012

What to Expect from Right-to-Work Legislation in Indiana

This week I released a study on some of the economic consequences of right-to-work legislation on manufacturing. This is work I have been involved with for a half decade. As with most scholarly work, this included reading nearly every study written on the matter and conducting my own statistical analysis over more than half a century. In it I accounted for such things as weather, regional effects, history and trends of manufacturing and traditional anti-union antipathy. It is an honest attempt to uncover the truth, but I don’t suppose this study will change many minds. It would be a long way from simply naïve to suppose that a limited study at this date from me would alter any decisions about right-to-work legislation in Indiana. That said, readers might be interested in what they might expect from this legislation.

The simple fact is that RTW states are growing faster than non-RTW states, but also have lower wages. But, this simple fact is merely correlation, not causation. My study, and a number of others designed for the academic market (as opposed to the policy realm), find far more muted effects of RTW.

First, there’s no good evidence that passing right-to-work will cause lower wages, poorer working conditions, significantly cut union funding of candidates (who are almost exclusively Democrats) or tangibly hurt unions. Indeed, as any casual observer will know, American unions have perfected their own destruction, and require no help from Indiana’s legislature in their epic quest for irrelevance. My study examined RTW legislation dating back to the Second World War (even before the Taft-Hartley Act), finding no statistically discernible effect on wages.

Second, while some studies have found modest job creation related to RTW, the best of these (which I discuss in my study) find no effects, or report that disentangling RTW from other business-friendly policies is nearly impossible. My study found no statistically viable evidence that RTW alters the share of manufacturing in a state, the size of the manufacturing industry in a state or manufacturing employment in a state.

Bottom line, we should expect no effect on manufacturing, for good or ill, in wages or employment as a consequence of RTW. That is, we should expect the ‘average effect’—which is nothing. However, it is also clear that some states have seen big positive impacts of RTW, while others have seen declines in their manufacturing sectors. Factors other than RTW are at play—a healthy business climate, responsible regulation and low tax rates matter in business relocation and expansion. As I have repeatedly said, these other factors already favor Indiana.

Clearly there are issues regarding RTW that my study does not address in detail. RTW and government costs were not examined. Likewise, I did not examine the service and retail sectors, where unions have targeted workplace rules, in so doing raising costs without tangibly benefitting workers. Most importantly, I did not examine the issue of freedom of choice, which seems to matter most.

Link to this commentary: https://commentaries.cberdata.org/605/what-to-expect-from-right-to-work-legislation-in-indiana

Tags: manufacturing, jobs and employment, income and wages, right-to-work and labor unions, law and public policy


About the Author

Michael Hicks cberdirector@bsu.edu

Michael J. Hicks, PhD, is the director of the Center for Business and Economic Research and the George and Frances Ball distinguished professor of economics in the Miller College of Business at Ball State University. Note: The views expressed here are solely those of the author, and do not represent those of funders, associations, any entity of Ball State University, or its governing body.

© Center for Business and Economic Research, Ball State University

About Ball State CBER Data Center

Ball State CBER Data Center is one-stop shop for economic data including demographics, education, health, and social capital. Our easy-to-use, visual web tools offer data collection and analysis for grant writers, economic developers, policy makers, and the general public.

Ball State CBER Data Center (cberdata.org) is a product of the Center for Business and Economic Research at Ball State University. CBER's mission is to conduct relevant and timely public policy research on a wide range of economic issues affecting the state and nation. Learn more.

Terms of Service

Center for Business and Economic Research

Ball State University • Whitinger Business Building, room 149
2000 W. University Ave.
Muncie, IN 47306-0360
Phone:
765-285-5926
Email:
cber@bsu.edu
Website:
www.bsu.edu/cber
Facebook:
www.facebook.com/BallStateCBER
Twitter:
www.twitter.com/BallStateCBER
Close