May 16, 2011
Gas Prices Again
For those of us with pickup trucks, the past few months have been a startling reminder of our dependence on gasoline. I think it is time to write a bit about what drives gas prices and why they are so high.
Of course the gas at the pump is set by the guy who owns the gas station. The owner is free to sell their gas for as little or as much as they wish. The problem is that most of them want to stay in business, and so will set a price that reflects the local market for gasoline. But in reality, most of us aren’t too worried about a few pennies a gallon difference between stations. It is the one dollar difference since January that matters to us. Here the story is a bit longer, but it is still about markets.
The change to a price of gasoline is almost wholly driven by the change in the price of oil. The reports we hear each day about the price of a barrel of oil is the futures price set on the commodities markets. This price is set by buyers and sellers who are trying to reduce the risk of price fluctuations on their companies. So, they may be oil producers, oil buyers, brokers, and buyers and sellers of other related commodities. In short, the commodities market is made up of thousands of buyers and sellers. Every time gas prices go up, some audacious attorney general embarks upon another fruitless investigation into speculation and price fixing. The problem is that no matter how high or low these prices go, for every sale there is a buyer who thinks prices will rise, and a seller who anticipates their decline. It is fundamental economics that drives gas price changes, and that is far more worrisome than speculation.
Oil prices are affected by the demand for petroleum products, the available supply of oil, by the value of the currency in which it is denominated and by uncertainty about future supply or demand shocks. So, to place the current prices into context, the world economy is recovering, and so worldwide demand for oil is rising. The recession and some domestic policy dampened new exploration for oil, and new petroleum infrastructure. This limits supply. So, higher demand, lower supply and prices necessarily rise. International uncertainty plays a factor, though the largest oil exporters are largely unaffected.
The real problem for Americans is that the value of our currency has been declining significantly. So, the cost of oil in dollars will necessarily rise to accommodate that decline. We are to blame for the slide of the dollar and this should serve as a timely reminder that the Stimulus and the two rounds of Quantitative Easing were not a free lunch.
Some good can come from this. We should all applaud President Obama’s calls for ending subsidies to oil companies or any energy producers for that matter. Just don’t expect it to change prices at the pump.
About the Author
Educational Attainment, the 21st Century Fund and the Future of SchoolingIndiana ranks 42nd in educational attainment.
Big Savings for Ending Prevailing WageMy statistical models show that repealing state prevailing wage laws save taxpayers money.
Re-Thinking Economic Development A large share of the most mobile families—perhaps half—no longer need to live near where they work.
Money Illusion and InflationPrice fluctuation could cause inflation to last longer, but it didn’t cause the inflation, it simply extends the pain.View archives