May 10, 2010
Fear Drives the Immigration Debate
The immigration debate deserves some straightforward economic reasoning. At the outset it is necessary to say something about Arizona’s new immigration law. This law simply makes the federal crime of illegal immigration also a crime against Arizonans. This allows police, in the course of normal law enforcement to check someone they suspect of illegally entering the country. This law is easy to label as racial profiling, for in Arizona it is certain it will be Mexicans, not the Quebecois most often detained. But this label is a spurious charge.
Mexico is in the throes of a violent lawlessness which is spilling over into the United States. Dealing with this is neither racist, nor unconstitutional -- though, that is not a particularly high bar for judging the efficacy of public policy. For those of us not living in the shadow of Mexico’s fluid lawlessness the immigration problem has an entirely different dimension. In the Midwest there are three issues.
First, illegal immigration does not steal American jobs. That’s simply not how the economy works. The work done by illegal immigrants is work that mostly would not otherwise be done without them. It is a pure gain to our economy. If an American loses a job to an illegal immigrant, that job is destined to disappear. The only question is where that work happens – either in a U.S. or Maquilodoran factory. I welcome the factories here.
Second, it is untrue that illegal immigrants cause a significant fiscal drain. They pay taxes, while using fewer services. But, even if this were a problem, the easiest fix is amnesty for illegal immigrants.
Finally, there’s a mistaken notion that immigrants do not benefit the country. This is counterfactual. Legal immigrants have both higher education levels and higher earnings on average than we native Americans. Economically, they are among our biggest national assets. Illegal immigrants also offer benefit, and perhaps more importantly the way they are treated is an important barometer of our national values. Here’s why.
I cannot imagine why my country would not welcome someone to our midst who would make the harrowing, difficult and dangerous journey from Mexico to the US to work. To work! Is there really any better expression of what we think of ourselves as Americans than this? What else could we expect from our fellow citizens?
One secular lesson is very important in my house. From time to time I carefully explain to my children that their forbears have fought in every American conflict from King Phillip’s War to Iraq, at Valley Forge, Chickamauga and D-Day. But, I make clear to my kids, that they are no more American, nor more deserving of citizenship and its benefits than any immigrant arriving this day at the Rio Grande or JFK Airport.
So once again, we are engaged in a national discussion of immigration. It is a difficult matter, full of real fear of violence. Fears of job losses are misplaced. This debate isn’t about economics. If it were there would be no discussion.
About the Author
Increasing Importance of Summer JobsThese jobs offer an opportunity to learn as well as earn money.
Educational Attainment, the 21st Century Fund and the Future of SchoolingIndiana ranks 42nd in educational attainment.
Big Savings for Ending Prevailing WageMy statistical models show that repealing state prevailing wage laws save taxpayers money.
Re-Thinking Economic Development A large share of the most mobile families—perhaps half—no longer need to live near where they work.View archives