October 31, 2011
Lessons in Macabre Taxes and Ghastly Fiscal Policy
It is once again that time of year when children turn either ghoulish or cute (or both). As I have noted in past columns, Halloween is the time when the Hicks’ kids learn about taxes. As a loving father, I combine the safety examination of their treats with a lesson on the effect of marginal tax rates on productivity. This year we will count out each bag of candy, and I will ‘tax’ the first 25 pieces at a 0% rate, the second 25 at a 5% rate and the rest at a 15% rate. This will help them better understand progressive taxation and reconsider how long to keep at the business of trick or treating as the benefits of doing so decline. I am not entirely heartless though, and will let them choose what candy they part with (though if they start liking Almond Joys, I might reconsider).
Unsurprisingly, my kids fear taxes. But, I also carefully explain to them that these taxes ‘pay’ for their costumes, the tennis shoes they sprint in, and the car ride to the lucrative neighborhood. It also buys a watchful eye from mom and dad. OK, that comes free, but it is a great metaphor for national defense. When I explain this to my kids, they sorta get the message, but are not as grateful as they should be. My college students often suffer a similar problem.
This year I will add a Stimulus Package to the game. Here’s how it will work. Our household, like everyone else’s, has lots of tasks in a typical week. We have swimming, baseball, soccer, algebra, spelling, geography, piano, pets, trash, dishes and laundry. A lot of work and enlightened self-interest motivates a lot of cooperation. It is literally a small economy though mom often helps in clarify exactly what self-interest entails (as in “if you know what’s good for you . . .”).
I dislike folding clothes. If you have been in the military, you know why. So this year, candy-taxes will be used to my advantage. By plying my kids with taxed treats I can ensure that I won’t fold clothes for at least two weeks. This only works on one child the others turn surly, make signs and go to protests.
Unfortunately, my kids have pointed out some problems with my Stimulus Plan. First, they say, “how is getting dad out of doing work consistent with the idea that these taxes are for all our good?” Second, “how is it fair that you take money from all of us, then pay one of us to do something that you want done but doesn’t really help the family?”
These are scary questions for which I have no good answer, except that it is good being dad. What is truly gruesome though is that those cute kids dressing up this Halloween will have to pay more than candy to fix the mess. That makes us grown-ups look like zombies.
About the Author
Increasing Importance of Summer JobsThese jobs offer an opportunity to learn as well as earn money.
Educational Attainment, the 21st Century Fund and the Future of SchoolingIndiana ranks 42nd in educational attainment.
Big Savings for Ending Prevailing WageMy statistical models show that repealing state prevailing wage laws save taxpayers money.
Re-Thinking Economic Development A large share of the most mobile families—perhaps half—no longer need to live near where they work.View archives