June 3, 2005
The Tax Coffers are Filling in Indiana
Is there such a thing as good news about taxes? Perhaps not. Muscles tense and faces frown at the mere sound of that three letter word. But you should know that there is a quiet tax increase occurring in the state of Indiana that few, if any, of its residents are complaining about. We’re all paying more in taxes to the state – quite a bit more, actually – and the Governor and the Legislature have very little to do with it.
What’s happening, of course, is that the economy is coming back to life, and with it, the base for most revenues is growing. That’s not a tax increase, of course, in the usual meaning of the term. But it’s more money coming out of our pockets and into public coffers, just the same. The difference is that when the base grows, we’ve got more to spend on ourselves, as well.
According to the monthly revenue reports published by the State Budget Agency, 2005 is shaping up to be a very good year for state revenues. In the case of the income tax, especially, the growth has been substantial. In the first quarter of the year, income tax collections were up almost 11 percent over the first three months of 2004. And in April, an important month for the income tax, revenues were up by almost $100 million over year-ago collections, a 19.2 percent rise.
Growth in sales tax receipts, while much more restrained, was still reasonably healthy. The last four quarters have seen collections average about 5.4 percent more than year-ago levels. Taken as a whole, the revenue situation for the state is better today than anytime in the last four years.
But if you think that this happy news will drive the word “taxes” off the front page for the next few years, you may be disappointed. Here’s a hint – there’s one very important tax in Indiana that I haven’t mentioned yet.
That’s right, the property tax. Its revenues haven’t surged with the economic recovery for the same reason that they didn’t fall when the economy was faltering. Even though the state has switched to an assessment method that is based on market value, the property tax base remains only very loosely connected to economic activity. And that makes it a tax that governments love, taxpayers hate, and very few people seem to actually understand.
We’re about to learn that what was called “comprehensive reform” of the property tax three years ago didn’t live up to that billing. Thanks to budget cuts and freezes by state government enacted this session, localities will be under more pressure to raise revenue locally to make up the difference. And the easiest way for them to do that is to raise property tax rates.
They’ll do it the same way they always have. That’s because even though the Tax Restructuring Act passed in 2002 shifted some of the property tax burden to the sales tax, it left the administrative and legal apparatus of tax rate determination intact. Thus we still have overlapping taxing jurisdictions, some with unelected boards, using potentially inconsistent township-level assessments, with the power to set rates to meet their revenue requirements.
It’s a system that has proven to be both cumbersome and unpopular. And the prospect of rate hikes to make up for shortfalls in revenue from the state house promises to put the question of our reliance on property taxes back on the front burner.
Like all questions about taxes, it doesn’t have an easy answer. What most Americans want – and what is impossible to give them – is a tax they can avoid. Failing that, a tax that rises and falls with their ability to pay is the next best option.
About the Author
Increasing Importance of Summer JobsThese jobs offer an opportunity to learn as well as earn money.
Educational Attainment, the 21st Century Fund and the Future of SchoolingIndiana ranks 42nd in educational attainment.
Big Savings for Ending Prevailing WageMy statistical models show that repealing state prevailing wage laws save taxpayers money.
Re-Thinking Economic Development A large share of the most mobile families—perhaps half—no longer need to live near where they work.View archives