April 15, 2013
Bourgeois Dignity and the Modern World
I have just read a most remarkable book, Bourgeois Dignity: Why Economics Can't Explain the Modern World, by Deirdre McCloskey, a distinguished professor of (get this) economics, history, English and communications at the University of Illinois, Chicago. It is part of a body of work making great waves in three academic disciplines. It is worth noting that Professor Deidre McCloskey has for some time been among the most revered of the big thinkers in economics, and was so when she was known as Don McCloskey. That is the focus of another of her books.
The main thesis of this book is that all the explanations of the explosion of economic growth that occurred about 300 years ago are inadequate. You see, from the beginning of recorded time until the 17th century, the average human lived daily on $3 worth of goods and services (in today's dollars). This means uncertain meals, two or perhaps three sets of clothes, and a short life lived within a hovel. Think of eastern Afghanistan or Pakistan, or Papua New Guinea today. About 300 years ago, in the western world this changed rapidly so that within three generations economic growth in western Europe and North America had exceeded all the recorded and archaeological history.
Several theories try to explain this. Some have failed spectacularly, such as those offered by Karl Marx, others explain only elements of that historical shift, such as modern economic growth theory. McCloskey argues (and I abbreviate dangerously) that sometime during the 1700's attitudes changed in a way that accepted a set of values, which have since been labeled as bourgeois. These include honesty, industry or effort, hope and faith in the future. Professor McCloskey argues that a belief in these values manifested itself in a few places in western Europe, and through observed changes to language and rhetoric (she cites Jane Austen's novels for example), gave what we might call the middle classes a dignity that had beforehand been reserved only for the nobility.
Once liberty was mixed with the dignity of what we might call middle class toil, an economic renaissance emerged. She recounts the spread of growth along with this rhetoric over the past two centuries. More importantly, McCloskey outlines where it continues to emerge in places where bourgeois dignity mixes with freedom: in India, China and Africa.
Like truly great intellectual innovations, it is simultaneously brilliant and once revealed so utterly simple that one is left wondering why it took so long to uncover. It is one of the great intellectual achievements of the new century. It should leave us asking some important questions. If the encouragement of a young Ben Franklin, Thomas Edison or Bill Gates is key to economic growth, how are we doing as a nation? Is the sort of industriousness that McCloskey argues propelled us from great poverty to great wealth still common or is it increasingly derided in popular culture? Has the rhetoric dignifying hard work been supplanted by valorization of easy riches and effortless talent? These are questions to ask one another, after reading this marvelous book.
About the Author
Educational Attainment, the 21st Century Fund and the Future of SchoolingIndiana ranks 42nd in educational attainment.
Big Savings for Ending Prevailing WageMy statistical models show that repealing state prevailing wage laws save taxpayers money.
Re-Thinking Economic Development A large share of the most mobile families—perhaps half—no longer need to live near where they work.
Money Illusion and InflationPrice fluctuation could cause inflation to last longer, but it didn’t cause the inflation, it simply extends the pain.View archives